A comparative study of the concept of justice in Islamic sociology and Western sociology (comparing the theory of justice in the thoughts of Martyr Morteza Motahari and John Rawls)
Volume 1, Issue 2, Summer 2025, Pages 62-79
https://doi.org/10.22034/jasd.2025.223981
Mehrshad Mirdar Najafi
Abstract Purpose: The purpose of this study was to conduct a comparative examination of the concept of justice in Islamic sociology and Western sociology, with a focus on the ideas of Martyr Morteza Motahhari and Michael Walzer. To derive a justice framework from the perspectives of these two thinkers, three layers of knowledge—philosophical (including epistemology, anthropology, and ontology), paradigmatic, and scientific (including theory and model)—were considered. Data were collected and analyzed using the comparative method.
Findings: The findings indicate that despite certain shared emphases—such as the importance both thinkers place on society and communal goods as well as the principles governing their distribution—Motahhari prioritizes the rights of society over the rights of individuals and disagrees with extensive relativism and maximal pluralism in social goods and distributive principles. He also maintains, unlike Walzer, that some universal and immutable perceptions of justice exist.
On the other hand, Walzer, by identifying eleven distinct spheres of justice (membership, security and welfare, money and commodities, office, hard work, leisure, education, kinship and love, recognition, divine grace, and political power), emphasizes the preservation of each sphere’s independence from domination and monopoly. Motahhari, however, identifies three broader domains of justice—divine justice, individual justice, and social justice—and argues for a comprehensive reciprocal relationship among them, in which divine justice forms the foundation of human justice, and individual justice underlies social justice.
Conclusion: Justice continues to be a central concern in socio‑economic and political thought. Although numerous social movements and political revolutions have sought to achieve justice and equality, there remains no universal agreement on the structure of a fully just society.
